Republican senators are privately criticizing President Trump’s handling of immigration, calling his aggressive deportation policies a misstep that could undermine the GOP’s electoral prospects in 2024. Concerns focus on how the approach is alienating key voting blocs, particularly in suburban districts where immigration has traditionally been a Republican strength. Lawmakers argue the strategy risks turning a once-reliable issue into a political liability, raising questions about the party’s ability to maintain its base while expanding its appeal. The internal debate highlights tensions between Trump’s hardline stance and the pragmatic concerns of Senate Republicans navigating a shifting electoral landscape.


Republican senators say President Trump has fumbled the issue of immigration, something that was an advantage for GOP candidates in 2024 but is now a growing political liability for their party. Several GOP senators told The Hill that Trump's deportation policy has gone too far and warn that it's hurting Republican candidates with suburban and...